Hiring guide
Counter-Offers: How to Keep the Engineer You Just Hired
Hiring for this role? We’ll benchmark it for your stage and send you the detail, free. Get a benchmark →
A counter-offer rarely appears out of nowhere. By the time one lands on your desk, the hiring process has usually left a gap for a current employer to walk through. Understanding why counter-offers land, and closing those gaps early, is a far more reliable strategy than trying to win a bidding war at the finish line.
Why counter-offers land
Most counter-offers succeed because they solve a narrow problem quickly. An engineer hands in their notice, their manager reacts with surprise and a number, and suddenly leaving feels riskier than staying. No commute change, no new team to learn, no probation period, just more pay. It is an easy decision to make under pressure, even if it rarely fixes the reasons they started looking in the first place.
This is why counter-offers are so common in competitive markets like fintech and AI, where specialist skills are scarce and employers know exactly what losing an engineer costs them in delay and disruption. See our notes on hiring in fintech and AI and data for how tight those markets are.
Warning signs during the process
Counter-offers do not come out of nowhere for the hiring manager either. Watch for a candidate going quiet between stages, pushing back the start date conversation, or becoming vague about when they plan to resign. A long gap between offer and resignation gives a current employer time to build a case for keeping them. The sooner notice is handed in after acceptance, the less room there is for a counter to develop.
Pricing the first offer correctly
Underpricing the initial offer is the single biggest reason counter-offers succeed. If a candidate accepts a role that is only marginally better than their current package, a modest rise from their existing employer can look just as good on paper. Benchmark properly before you make an offer, using current salary benchmarks or our UK tech salary statistics, and for a fuller market view see the UK Tech Salary Report 2026. A correctly priced offer should feel like a clear step forward, not a close call.
This matters across disciplines, whether you are hiring software engineers, DevOps engineers, or data engineers, and particularly for scarce skill sets such as TypeScript, Node.js and Python developers, where competing offers are common.
Keeping candidates close through notice periods
The period between signed offer and start date is when deals are won or lost. Keep contact regular and low pressure: a check-in call, an invite to a team event, early access to onboarding material. Silence during this window leaves space for a current employer to fill with attention and promises. Treat the notice period as part of the hiring process, not the point where it ends.
What to do when a counter-offer arrives
If a candidate tells you they have received a counter-offer, resist the urge to immediately raise your own number. Ask what has actually changed on their side and remind them, calmly, why they started the conversation with you. A pay rise rarely addresses the lack of progression, poor management, or stagnant scope that usually prompts someone to look elsewhere. Most engineers who accept a counter-offer end up leaving within a year regardless, once the short-term fix wears off.
How we help
At OpenSource, every candidate we put forward has already been technically screened by the founders, so you are hiring people who are serious about moving, not testing the market. We help you price offers correctly, manage notice periods properly, and reduce the chances of a counter-offer derailing a hire, across contingent, retained search and embedded recruitment engagements, and for roles across London and beyond. See our full services or our software engineering recruitment page, or get in touch to talk through a live hire.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Why do counter-offers work so often?
They remove the hardest part of leaving, the uncertainty, without the engineer having to change anything else. The current employer already knows them, the commute and team are familiar, and more pay with none of the risk of a new job is an easy yes in the moment.
Should we increase our first offer to beat a possible counter-offer?
Not blindly. The better approach is pricing the first offer correctly against current market data, so the candidate never feels they left money behind by accepting. Overpaying to pre-empt a counter you may never see is wasteful and resets your benchmarks for every future hire.
What should we do the moment a counter-offer is mentioned?
Stay calm, ask what was actually offered, and remind the candidate why they started looking in the first place. A pay rise rarely solves the original reason for leaving. Avoid getting into a bidding war over the phone.
How long should we stay in touch during a notice period?
From signed offer to start date, not just the first week. Regular, low-pressure contact keeps your offer front of mind and gives early warning if the candidate is wavering.